Where a release of liability stops working
A release is a contract, and like any contract there are things it cannot do. Three limits matter more than the rest. The first is the conduct line. Almost everywhere, a release can cover ordinary negligence but not conduct that goes beyond it. California puts the rule in statute: Civil Code section 1668 says contracts that aim to exempt anyone from responsibility for their own fraud, willful injury to another, or violation of law are against the policy of the law, and in City of Santa Barbara v. Superior Court (2007) the state supreme court held that a release of future gross negligence is unenforceable too. Clause 3 of the template carves all of that out immediately after the release itself, because a release drafted to cover everything invites a court to strike more of it than necessary. The second is the kind of business involved. In Tunkl v. Regents of the University of California (1963), California set out six characteristics of a contract affecting the public interest, among them a business of a type usually thought suitable for public regulation, a service of practical necessity offered to all comers, unequal bargaining power, a standard form with no option to pay for protection, and a customer placed under the provider's control. Courts in many states run through a version of that list, and a release that fits it is at risk whatever it says. The third is state law that voids releases outright. New York's General Obligations Law section 5-326 makes a release void and unenforceable where a pool, gymnasium, place of amusement or recreation, or similar establishment charges a fee for use. Virginia goes further still, through its courts rather than a statute: in Hiett v. Lake Barcroft Community Association (1992) its supreme court confirmed that a pre-injury release of liability for personal injury is void there. Montana voids such contracts in section 28-2-702 of its code, then allows an exception for sport and recreation, discussed below. Louisiana treats a clause excluding liability in advance for causing physical injury as null under article 2004 of its Civil Code. Check your own state before relying on a signature.